Get Permission Rajalakshmi, Keshava, Irodi, and Rabi: Cross sectional anatomy - need for uniformity in the display of medical images or line diagram while representing the anatomical structures


Introduction

There were differences in the ways anatomists and radiologists approach cross-sectional anatomy. If learning cross-sectional anatomy and subsequent imaging anatomy are in the same orientation, a potential scope for wrong identification of the side can be avoided. This manuscript tries to point out the steps taken by anatomists to integrate teaching of Anatomy with clinical teaching.

Figure 1
https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/3a0ee152-3400-47ed-8b3e-f1c44b2fdb61/image/e3d3c38b-4430-43ad-8686-da3f8c513414-u13a.png

Figure 2
https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/3a0ee152-3400-47ed-8b3e-f1c44b2fdb61/image/d5dbcdfa-c7f7-4beb-b5ac-a6e36f3da74e-u10a.png

Table 1
Name of the book Images are viewed from
From Head end From Foot end Mixed (some images were viewed from head end, some from foot end)
Cunningham’s Manual of Practical Anatomy + (Upto 15th edition) + (16th edition) -
Gray’s Anatomy, The Anatomical basis of Clinical Practice + (Upto 38th edition) + ( From 40th edition ) + (39th edition)
Clinical Anatomy: Harold Ellis + (Upto 9th edition ) (10th, 11th, 12th editions were not available in the library.) - + (13th edition)
Human Sectional Anatomy, Atlas of Body sections, CT and MRI images, by Harold Ellis, Bari M Logan, Adrian K Dixon - + (3rd and 4th editions ) -
An Atlas of Anatomy: J.C.Boileau Grant - - + (5th, 10th, 14th editions)
Last’s Anatomy, Regional and Applied + (Upto 7th edition : for cross-sections through limbs-orientation not mentioned) (8th, 9th, 11th editions were not checked as they were unavailable). - + (10th, 12th editions)
Clinical Anatomy for Medical students: Richard S.Snell - - + (4th to 9th edition)
Clinical oriented Anatomy: Keith L Moore - - + (2nd to 7th edition)
Colour Atlas of Human Anatomy: McMinn - - + (2nd to 6th edition)
Illustrated Clinical Anatomy by Peter Abraham, John Craven, John Lumley - - + (For some cross-sectional images, orientation is not mentioned)
Textbook of Human Anatomy: Hamilton, 2nd edition + - (For some cross-sectional images, orientation is not mentioned)
Detailed atlas of the Head and Neck by Truex and Kellner - - +
Atlas of Human Anatomy: Lopetz- Antunez + - -
Anatomy, a photographic Atlas by Rohen, Yokochi, Lutjen-Drecoll - - + (8th edition: for some cross-sections orientation is not mentioned.)
Atlas of Human Anatomy: Frank.H.Netter - - + (2nd to 6th edition)
Workbook for a cross-sectional approach to anatomy: Roy R.Peterson - + -
An atlas of cross-sectional anatomy, Computed tomography, Ultrasound, Radiography, Gross anatomy: Stephen A.Kieffer, E.Robert Heitzman - + -
Basic atlas of sectional anatomy with correlated imaging: J.Bo W, Carr JJ, A.Krueger W, T. Woleman N, L. Bowden R - + (1st, 2nd, 4th editions.) (3rd edition was not available) -
The visible human body, Indian edition: Von Hagens G, J Romrell L, H.Ross M, Tiedemann K. - + -
Living anatomy, Robert A.Novelline, Lucy Frank Squire - + (but orientation is not mentioned in some cross-sections) -
A cross-sectional anatomy: Albert C. Eycleshymer, Daniel M. Shoemaker + - -

Table depicting the name of the books and their way of display of cross-sectional images/ line diagrams

[i] (For some of the books, the older editions were not available in the library.)

Sectional anatomy has had a long history, enjoyed wide popularity during 19th century, but its application to study anatomy declined during early 20th century. It cannot be said with certainty who had started the study of cross-sectional anatomy, but it was used in 16th century, which was evident from the drawings of Leonardo da Vinci.1

With the advent of radiological techniques, such as Computed Tomography (CT) and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), cross-sectional anatomy regains its importance. It is not only mandatory for the radiologists, but also for the surgeons, physicians, students of Anatomy to learn cross-sectional anatomy in order to interpret these images and provide quality health care for the patients.1, 2, 3, 4, 5 Knowledge of cross-sectional Anatomy helps the students to get a three dimensional view of the organs, their relationship with one another, retaining the information for a longer duration.2, 4, 6

The books which were published earlier displayed the cross-sectional anatomy images as viewed from the head end down as it was considered as rational standard/clinical position.7 As per the standard Anatomical Position, the structures and their relations of various organs are described even when the body is lying on the back in the bed, or in the dissecting table, assuming as if the person is standing upright with the feet together and the head and eyes are looking to the front, with the arms straight by the side and the palms of the hands facing forwards. I assume that this may be the reason for describing the cross-sectional images from the head end in those days.

Albert Einstein said, “I never teach my pupils, I only provide the conditions in which they can learn.” Thus to meet the demands of the students learning cross-sectional anatomy to identify the structures in CT, MRI where the equipment produces images as viewed from the foot end up, the authors of the Anatomy and Cross-sectional Anatomy books have changed their approach and nowadays, in all the atlases, the orientation of the image is in line with the CT/MRI axial images.2, 3, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18

“A Cross sectional Anatomy” by C. Eycleshymer A, M. Schoemaker D.(published in 1911), projected the cross-sections from the head end. Even the Cunningham’s Manual of Practical Anatomy upto the 15th edition also displayed the cross-sections from the head end. But the recent edition (16th edition) displays the cross-sections from the foot end.

To summarise, the cross-sections of thorax, abdomen were described from foot end by most of the textbooks, while the cross-sections of the extremities and brain were given in different patterns in different textbooks and for some of the cross-sections through neck and extremities, the orientation was not mentioned.

Identifying a correct side is important in the medical practice. For example, when an externally invisible unilateral tumour requiring surgical excision is diagnosed, there should not be any error of identifying the correct side. If learning cross sectional anatomy and subsequent imaging anatomy are in the same orientation, a potential scope for wrong identification of the side can be avoided.

The front cover of the 41st edition of Gray’s Anatomy, The Anatomical basis of Clinical Practice shows the image of orientation of the white fibres in the brain using “Advanced Diffusion Tractography”. For me, this implies that the anatomists understood the need to revise the traditional methods of teaching anatomy and to integrate with other basic sciences and clinical teaching.

References

1 

Anatomy Atlases: Atlas of Human Anatomy in Cross Section: Introduction and Explanatory Note; July 20172017http://www.anatomyatlases.org/HumanAnatomy/IntroExplanatoryNote.shtml

2 

Why Study Cross-Sections? July 20172017http://webanatomy.com/CSA/cross_objectives.asp

3 

The National Library of Medicines Visible Human Project; July 2017https://www.nlm.nih.gov/research/visible/visible_human.html

4 

C S Oh J Y Kim Y H Choe Learning of cross-sectional anatomy using clay modelsAnat Sci Educ200924156159

6 

T Del Junco Jr K A Emmons K T Sim E C Ang B Goldstein A W Fleming The Utilization of Cross-Sectional Anatomy in a Surgical Residency Training ProgramJ Natl Med Assoc1987793289

7 

C Eycleshymer A M Schoemaker D A Cross sectional Anatomy. Appleton and Company; 19111911

8 

A Kieffer S E R Heitzman An Atlas of cross-sectional anatomy. Harper & Row Publishers; 19791979

9 

J Bo W J J Carr A Krueger W T Woleman N L Bowden R Basic Atlas of Sectional Anatomy with correlated imaging. 4th editionReed Elsevier India Private Ltd2009

10 

H Ellis M Logan B K Dixon A Human Sectional Anatomy, Atlas of body sections, CT and MRI images. 3rd edition. Hodder Arnold Education; 2007.2007

11 

Living Anatomy. C.V. Mosby Company; 19871987

12 

G Von Hagens L Romrell L H Ross M K Tiedemann The visible human body an atlas of sectional anatomyK M Varghese Company1991

13 

R Peterson R Workbook for cross-sectional anatomy. R.R.Peterson Publications; 1982

14 

H Ellis Clinical Anatomy A Revision and Applied Anatomy for Clinical Students. 11th editionBalckwell Publishing Ltd

15 

S Snell R Clinical Anatomy by Regions. 9th editionWilliams and WilkinsLippincott

16 

L Moore K F Dalley A M R Ahur A Clinically Oriented Aantomy. 7th editionWilliams and WilkinsLippincott

17 

G J Romanes Cunningham’s Manual of Practical Anatomy. 15th edition2Oxford University Press

18 

S Standring Gray’s Anatomy The Anatomical Basis of Clinical Practice. 41st editionElsevier



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File  


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.ijcap.2019.112


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 2630

PDF Downloaded: 1238